Animation glitch in item expansion under macOS

Animation glitch in item expansion under macOS

#90Bug

Under macOS Sequoia and any Kosshi version, I see an annoying animation flick when click-expanding an item (i.e. clicking on its small arrow). When unfolding its nested lines, whatever number of them, even a single one, the whole nested block "flickers", or "bumps" for a split second, making the usage of the macOS version very uncomfortable for me.

Such effect is so evident that for several months I believed it only affected me, not having seen any report about. So, I carefully checked any possible "default" CLI custom setting I might have set, before reporting here myself. Unfortunately, I found no solution, and I have to conclude that the expanding animation is not working properly, at least for me.

Three notable findings are the following:

  1. The flicker effect does not show neither in iOS and iPadOS.
  2. The flicker effect gets widely improved by enabling the "Reduce motion" feature in System Settings -> Accessibility -> Display. It becomes instead replaced by the expected substitute cross-fade effect, which is still better than the broken animation.
  3. The effect only appears when expansion is activated by click. Instead, the unfolding is totally smooth as expected when triggered by the Command-arrow-down shortcut. This is truly weird.

However, I wouldn't like to be forced to keep Reduce motion on forever, as I expect Kosshi will become a main information management app for me.

Indeed, the impact of number (2) above shows that the flick effect is strictly related to the expected expand animation not working properly, for some reason, under some circumstances that I couldn't isolate better than this.

I can provide supporting short videos if helpful.

Hi uramaki,

Thanks for the detailed report and for trying out various settings and actions. I'm sorry for the inconvenience.

I've worked on this kind of flickering a few times since early development, but it looks like I hadn't fixed it. I haven't seen it much recently, but I've now confirmed it again.

I'm continuing to investigate and work on a fix.

Thanks for digging into this and sharing your findings.

As a minimal temporary, quick, workaround, it seems that the "expansion-click" and "Command-arrow-down" actions follow different code paths. It would be great if you could just apply the second such one for both actions, since it seems to work fine already. Thanks for your consideration.

Delete post

The post body and edit history will be removed. A quiet marker remains only when visible replies link to this post.

Open original